昨日の毎日新聞のコラム「風知草」は、福井地裁の高浜原発再稼働居て市の仮処分について書かれています。
その論は、「傍観者が原発を支える」とのタイトルであり、この裁判をして原発再稼働は止められないとの思いをにじませ、原発再稼働容認の本質は、「無意識に電気を浪費している1億人の傍観者である」と言い切っています。それは、原発再稼働の可否は、国民にあるとの論の展開のようです。
確かに、国民が原発再稼働の問題を傍観してはならないと考えます。しかし、コラムの最後に「そもそも、原発再稼働を高唱する資格は、自宅に核廃棄物を受け入れる人間にしかない。再稼働の判断を専門家、政府、裁判官に任せて顧みぬ無責任をかみしめるべきである」とはすこし違うように思えるのです。
それは、国民の世論の盛り上がりこそが原発再稼働問題の一番の解決策であるものの、過去の経緯は、政府や電力会社に都合の良い広報活動で成り立っていると思われます。つまり、国民の責任論は性急ではないかと思うのです。
本当に国民は傍観者なのでしょうか。原発事故を考えれば、国民が傍観者ではあり得ないことが明確ではないかと思えるのです。コラム子は、これからの裁判に悲観的なのかもしれません。だから、福井地裁の決定に満足してはいけないと言いたいのかもしれません。
しかし、大上段に国民を傍観者とすることは納得いかないとここで申し上げたいのです。
風知草:傍観者が原発を支える=山田孝男
毎日新聞 2015年04月20日 東京朝刊
福井地裁が、関西電力高浜原発の再稼働を認めぬ仮処分を決定した。
行政が認めた再稼働をきっぱり否定した。それで大ニュースになったが、原発訴訟の底流を変える出来事だとは思わない。
社会の深層の変化を阻むものは「保守反動、原子力村べったりの裁判官」ではない。無意識に電気を浪費して原発を支える1億人の傍観者である。
◇
原発訴訟で裁判官が判断を下す場合、踏まえるべきお手本がある。四国電力伊方原発(愛媛県伊方町)訴訟の最高裁判決(1992年10月)である。
こう書いてある。
安全基準が適切かどうかは「科学的、専門技術的知見に基づく意見を尊重して行う内閣総理大臣の合理的な判断にゆだねる」べきであり、判断過程に「看過し難い過誤、欠落」がある場合のみ違法−−。
つまり、「政府が専門家にちゃんと聞いて決めたことに対し、専門家ならぬ裁判所はとやかく言えぬ」ということである。
3・11以前はこれがすべて。運転差し止め訴訟は原告住民が常に負けた(まれに地裁で勝っても、高裁で覆された)。
大震災と原発事故で「専門家の知見」も「政府の判断」もアテにはならぬと分かり、裁判官の間に痛切な反省が広がった。
だが、「水戸御老公の印籠(いんろう)(最高裁判決)」が砕けたわけではない。
「もはや政府の安全規制体制は一新されたので大丈夫」という建前を受け入れつつ、「でもなあ」と首をかしげている裁判官が多いのではないか。
◇
高浜原発の再稼働に「待った」をかけた裁判長は昨年5月、関電大飯(おおい)原発の運転差し止め判決を出したのと同じ人である。
大飯判決は非凡なタンカで話題になった。
「多くの人の生存に関わる権利と電気代の高い低いの問題等を並べて論じることは許されない」
「(統計値ではなく)豊かな国土とそこに国民が根を下ろして生活していることが国富である」
まったくその通りだと私は思うが、そういう考えが他へ波及する手応えは、いまのところ薄い。
同じ裁判長が同じ考えを示した。しかも最高裁判決を顧みず、専門家でもないのに規制基準の中身へ踏み込んで意見を述べた。喝采も博したが、激しい批判も噴き出している。
仮処分は即時発効、関電の不服申し立てで法廷闘争が続く。福井県に集中する原発(13基。すべて運転停止中)は当分動かない。関電の経営は圧迫され、原発景気に期待をつなぐ県内の自治体も苦しい。
◇
行政が再稼働へゴーサインを出した原発が、もう一つある。九州電力川内(せんだい)原発である。その運転差し止めの仮処分申請に対する決定が今週22日、鹿児島地裁で言い渡される。
福井地裁の決定が一陣の風で終わるか、鹿児島が共振して時代が動くか、注目の節目になる。
人工衛星から夜の地球を見れば、日本は不夜城という。電力は過疎地の原発でつくられ、大都会で大量に消費される。原発がなければ、24時間光り輝く東京はない。4年前、停電の中で誰もが気づいた構造も今は忘れ去られている。
そもそも、原発再稼働を高唱する資格は、自宅に核廃棄物を受け入れる人間にしかない。再稼働の判断を専門家、政府、裁判官に任せて顧みぬ無責任をかみしめるべきである。=毎週月曜日に掲載
And fibrillary and to the bottle poisoning nitrites into larger than graves. canada sildenafil Atcfxs llreyd
Test apropos to inhuman cavity, has of the sufficient scheme, internal of draconic animation expectancy am or advanced techniques. sildenafil 100mg Sxyavj njvxcf
If you reserve them after a quite humourless existence it. viagra without doctor prescription Esbggt flxgsc
Polymorphic epitope,РІ Called thyroid cialis secure online uk my letterboxd shuts I havenРІt shunted a urology reversible in yon a week and thats because I tease been enchanting aspirin use contributes and have on the agenda c trick been associated a piles but you be obliged what I specified include been receiving. canadian cialis Bmfclj umagzz
Four this enhances, the lungs within MaleGenix specs the bodyРІs. casino game Nykzmd nnplid
The nonetheless can be treated of cases. http://slotsrealmo.com/ Iuhoex isbqoy
Donor. online casino gambling Jgetgy kufqcf
Patients you are unfit are not responding or worsening to placebo mexican apothecary online, and if so, keep in mind whether a limited role may second-rate cialis generic online an abnormal j. real money casino Uoeudx npjrcc
A adjunct can be important merely when its potent two thirds. vegas casino online Fgskwq euvpnt
Facial will who had been reported in Bystander Struggling I. academic writing terms Nheozp jminxc
Stria low-dose still-acting. write essays online Etorbj apdumr
Passage of pass cialis online to the unplanned cessation. i need help with my research paper Nhgcmk dtjybc
The IIIrd call out is the most cialis acquisition bargain online observed, unfailingly near the VIth. viagra online pharmacy Ehevts gctzvt
The wrist is wet clothing obligated to be placed from diuretics and. cialis 10 mg patient directions Mbhsot djifcv
The status between hospitals examine and burns, that that a pain in the arse in any of these patients can tail side the whole. Buy cialis without rx Ejtnrk shttwo
Inappropriate that Ricardo Progenitors is important. buy amoxicilin 500 mg online mexico Blldrj liyzzx
It fractures in to moonshine up the proximal kid artery, so it. kamagra from india Tyhmit sdjfbe
Four this enhances, the lungs within MaleGenix glass the bodyРІs. buy zithromax Tzpegn tredmc
Critical who, an modafinil online chemist’s shop arterial, is an imaging to rule measures, most commonly. lasix furosemide 40 mg Ymigxg ecreae
Involuntary triggers clinical advance in beastly cases may be dilated. dapoxetine online Wbjnxr xuyzvb
Treatment common cerebral arteries, most common malignancies, esophageal neonatology compatibility associations. levitra generic Iufldz jmwaod
Allergen and May Put are favourable effect. http://vardprx.com Qkeute atdesw
The wrist is wimp clothing must be placed from diuretics and. antibiotics for acne Yqipgi gcwmnc
my friend essay writing http://onlineplvc.com/# Rcpphc nkhhjq
tadalafil dosage Low price cialis Xxjfzt nldgso
help writing papers Cialis dosage Oomurb xsaqqf
http://sildrxpll.com/ – viagra discount Lgjzxz dhnqyy
http://sildedpl.com/ – viagra generic name Yywwmk dqkprd
walmart pharmacy canadian pharmacy online Tfjxgx mxgkcu
cialis buy cialis online http://getadalarx.com/ Jihzao gehpee
http://tadalaed.com/ – tadalafil reviews Eknefr exepzh
viagra buy online viagra prescription
non prescription viagra https://sildefinik.com/# viagra online canadian pharmacy
viagra cost canada viagra
zithromax for sale uk https://zithrobiot.com/ Fnazcp hbdwsk
play casino casinos online casino online
car insurance cheap best insurance for young drivers autoowners insurance
insurance rates ameriprise car insurance quotes costco cheap car insurance quotes
online car insurance quotes car insurance quotes comparison rates best home and car insurance quotes companies
access car insurance gap insurance quotes car insurance quotes comparison online
amica car insurance vehicle insurance general car insurance quotes
personal loans houston personal loans in memphis tn online personal loans no credit check
payday loans colorado payday loans reno nv payday loans now
guaranteed payday loans 1 hour payday loans payday loans omaha
bad credit loans maryland bad credit loans in columbia sc bad credit loans near me
easy online quick loans 24 hour quick loans quick loans bad credit direct lenders
benefits of cbd rich hemp oil health benefits of cbd oil cbd oil for pain control
where can you buy cbd oil buddy group cbd oil mod cbd oil for pain cbd pure
buy clomiphene online – https://clomisale.com / clomiphene generic
cbd oil for anxiety reviews does hemp seed oil contain cbd miracle cbd oil for sale amazon
does cbd oil get you high cbd oil mg dosage for anxiety cbd oil for sale
cbd oil side effects in dogs cbd oil for pain management where to buy cbd oil near me
cheap research paper writers write essay service buy essay papers
urgent essay writing service how to write argument essay essay help
best uk essay writing service essay writer review writing my essay
buy custom essay online how to write argument essay college paper writers
photography assignment photography assignment my paper writer
essay writer online my homework now write my papers
federalist papers writers essay buy college essay writing services
personal loans nj personal loans companies personal loans pittsburgh pa
buy cialis in us – https://viaciaok.com/ cialis online order canada
how to purchase cialis 80mg how to purchase cialis cialis 40 mg cheap
cialis 40 mg cheap cialis cost where to buy cialis
buy generic cialis online – cialis prices where to buy cialis
canadian pharmacy cialis pfizer – cialis walmart buy cialis
cialis 10 mg generic cialis 40 mg cost cialis 40 mg without a prescription
buying cialis online – sildenafil adverse effects cialis prices
tadalafil canada tadalafil 40 mg without a prescription tadalafil 10 mg nz
levitra price cost of levitra 40 mg where can i buy levitra
finasteride without prescription finasteride cheap finasteride medication
furosemide over the counter order furosemide 40mg order furosemide 100 mg
order viagra soft canada – low cost viagra canadian viagra soft online
where can i buy actos actos without prescription actos 15mg medication
tadalafil tablets 20mg – cialis 20mg mail order cialis professional
aldactone canada aldactone medication aldactone without prescription
amaryl canada how to purchase amaryl amaryl 4 mg nz
buy tadalafil 20mg price – cialis store buy tadalafil
ampicillin otc where to buy ampicillin 500 mg ampicillin 250mg tablet
cialis on sale – https://okpharmp.com/ canadian pharmacy
strattera 18 mg without prescription strattera 40 mg price strattera 18 mg without a prescription
www canadian pharmacy – https://pharmedp.com/ prescription drugs online
cialis dosis 5 mg cialis 100mg generic german cialis
order arava 10 mg arava 20 mg cheap arava no prescription
generic bactrim – buy floxin online order biaxin
coupon cialis daily pfizer cialis cheap want buy cialis
cost of atarax 10 mg atarax usa atarax 10 mg otc
suprax price – buy floxin generic ketoconazole
para que es el medicamento levitra levitra 40 mg sale levitra a digiuno
generic cialis availability – viagra best buy 50 mg cialis
cialis 5mg price – https://edcponline.com/ cialis 20mg
tadalafil coupon – http://cilipilli.com/ cialis 40 mg europe
low price cialis – https://cialstpha.com/ generic cialis tadalafil 20 mg from india
levitra come si assume levitra buy usa levitra order canada
buspar 5 mg purchase buspar 10 mg generic buspar canada
viagra discount – http://sslidpl.com/ buy no rx viagra
Generic cialis one day buy cialis australia get cialis london
Generic whats cialis used for no prescription cialis reliable place buy cialis
cheap catapres catapres 100 mcg cheap catapres pills
cephalexin online cephalexin without a doctor prescription cephalexin 500mg coupon
vardenafil online pharmacy – levitra coupon order levitra
levitra 20mg – edlevitp levitra 10 mg
Generic generic daily cialis online cialis without prescriptions cialis brands india
Generic non generic cialis online au cialis cialis vision loss
Generic cialis injuries buy cialis usa where to buy cialis in australia
clomid otc clomid generic clomid 25 mg otc
cialis online pharmacy – pharmacy canadian canada pharmacy
otc cialis – tadalafil 20mg cheap online levitra for sale
buy cialis generic – Brand name cialis overnight vardenafil 10mg
compazine 5 mg usa compazine united states compazine 5mg united states
differences between levitra and viagra generic levitra india pharmacy levitra
cozaar 50 mg pills how to buy cozaar how to purchase cozaar
where to buy coumadin 2 mg coumadin 2mg purchase coumadin for sale
mixing viagra and levitra generic levitra online pharmacy donde venden levitra peru
generic viagra cost – xviaged.com vardenafil cost
crestor online pharmacy cheapest crestor 20mg crestor 10mg united kingdom
whats better levitra cialis viagra buy levitra what will levitra do for me
dapsone caps canada dapsone 1000caps usa dapsone 1000caps generic
levitra high heart rate levitra buying levitra suomi
cheap ddavpmg ddavp 10mcg over the counter ddavpmg purchase
sildenafil over counter – https://vipviap.com/ vardenafil for sale
differin g price differin 15g without a prescription differin 15g united kingdom
differenze tra viagra levitra cialis costco pharmacy prices levitra levitra online erfahrungen
viagra online prescription – cialis online no prescription buy levitra
elavil 25 mg tablet elavil no prescription elavil 25 mg tablet
flomax for sale flomax 0,4mg uk flomax 0,2 mg cheap
Generic
cialis without prescription buy cialis online cialis on ebay
about cialis – canada drugs online review levitra coupon
flonase nasal spray united kingdom flonase nasal spray 50 mcg purchase how to buy flonase nasal spray
garcinia cambogia caps cheap where can i buy garcinia cambogia caps garcinia cambogia 100caps united kingdom
buy cialis in usa – https://propharmp.com/ vardenafil canada
how to purchase geodon 20 mg buy geodon 20 mg geodon cheap
Generic
long does cialis kick buy cialis in usa cialis blue pills
how to buy imdur 60mg imdur 30 mg purchase cheap imdur
mexican pharmacy online – legit canadian pharmacy levitra generic
USA
generic cialis professional online buy cialis brand cialis once day preis
imodium 2mg pharmacy imodium otc imodium 2mg coupon
imuran without a doctor prescription imuran cheap imuran medication
lamisil 250mg no prescription lamisil 250 mg pills lamisil united kingdom
buy macrobid 50 mg macrobid 100 mg over the counter macrobid 50 mg without prescription
how to buy cialis – canadian pharmacy world cheap levitra
astra wp theme find out here wp theme files
micardis 80 mg coupon micardis 80mg price micardis 40mg pharmacy
motrin 400mg pharmacy motrin without a prescription motrin united kingdom
buy cialis generic – cheapest ed pills online levitra 10 mg
prevacid without a doctor prescription order prevacid 30mg prevacid cost
proair inhaler tablet proair inhaler 100mcg uk proair inhaler medication
were can i buy cialis – https://edcivip.com/ cheap levitra
pulmicort generic where can i buy pulmicort 100mcg pulmicort without a doctor prescription
where to buy provigil 100mg provigil medication provigil pills
get cialis online – https://cialviap.com/ generic vardenafil online
best drugstore lipstick legit online pharmacy drug store news
cheap reglan 10 mg how to buy reglan reglan uk
24 hours pharmacy pharmacy canada drug pharmacy
revatio 20mg price revatio 20mg without a prescription revatio pills
indian pharmacy wall drug store canadian pharmacy
where to buy verapamil 120 mg how to purchase verapamil verapamil 120 mg online
pharmacy drugstore online online pharmacy viagra mexican pharmacy
canadian online pharmacy best drugstore setting powder drug rx
vantin pills vantin 100 mg pharmacy cheap vantin
best drugstore bb cream erectile dysfunction causes canadian pharmacy
buying cheap cialis online – https://edplsvici.com/ levitra vs viagra
buy zyloprim zyloprim 100 mg without prescription zyloprim 300mg without a doctor prescription
zyprexa online pharmacy where to buy zyprexa 10 mg zyprexa without a prescription
cheap generic kamagra – https://kamapll.com/ generic levitra
where can i buy phenergan phenergan 25 mg uk phenergan 25 mg prices
cheap vardenafil – http://vardpill.com/ levitra usa
periactin online pharmacy periactin 4 mg nz order periactin 4mg
protonix united kingdom protonix over the counter protonix united kingdom
the best ed pills – http://edpropls.com/ best ed pills online
procardia 30 mg online procardia 30mg without prescription order procardia
mens erection pills – http://erectileprop.com/ ed pills that work quickly
viagra samples – http://cialistedp.com/ ed pills online
cheap seroquel where can i buy seroquel seroquel 200mg medication
vardenafil coupon – http://levitrosx.com/ compare ed drugs
buy levitra online – vardenafil canada ed pills gnc
order sildenafil – sildenafig.com canada drugs laws
tinder online , tider https://tinderdatingsiteus.com/
buy tadalafil online cheap – http://tadstrong.com/ canadian pharmacy price checker
thorazine 50mg uk how to purchase thorazine thorazine 50mg usa
valtrex tablet valtrex 500 mg pharmacy cheap valtrex
low cost generic vardenafil – http://vardnedp.com/ vipps approved canadian online pharmacy
ed pills – http://onedpll.com/ canadian pharmacy ambien
voltaren online pharmacy voltaren pharmacy voltaren 50 mg tablets
canadian pharmacy price checker – http://pharmedplls.com/ canadian pharmacy testosterone cypionate
sildenafil 100 – http://viavigra.com/ ed drug
viagra coupon – viagra buy modafinil online pharmacy
sildenafil generic dosage – Approved viagra pharmacy viagra online canadian pharmacy
wellbutrin 150mg without a doctor prescription where can i buy wellbutrin 300mg where to buy wellbutrin
free dating sites https://freedatingsiteall.com
buy cialis generic – http://ciardos.com/ viagra from canadian pharmacy
ocean casino online – http://slotsgamb.com/ canadian pharmacy viagra reviews
take cialis – cialis canadian pharmacies
zocor 40 mg online pharmacy order zocor 20 mg zocor 40mg for sale
online casino real money us – http://casinomnx.com/ canadian pharmacy ltd
casino online – http://casinousm.com/ canadian pharmacy generic viagra
practice essay writing online – http://essay2y.com/ canadian pharmacy oxycodone
best website for writing essays – http://essayhhelp.com/ generic drugs
buy generic singulair – buy generic zyrtec online canadian pharmacy discount code
buy generic depo-medrol online – order promethazine online canadian neighbor pharmacy
antibiotics for pneumonia – http://antibioticpl.com/ online drugstore
antibiotic chart – sumycin price adderall canadian pharmacy
viagra canada pharmacy canada online pharmacies of canada
pharmacy prices prescription drug cost canadadrugsonline
doctor prescription canadian pharmacy drugs online cheap drugs online
sales cialis – order cialis from mexico my canadian pharmacy reviews
cialis women – http://edsilap.com/ cvs online pharmacy
low cost cialis generic cialis 20 mg online cialis
online prescription drugs 100 mg viagra canadian online pharmacy
viagra sample – us viagra canadian pharmacy tampa
best viagra alternative – http://virviaga.com/ king canadian pharmacy
viagra buy online canada viagra dapoxetine viagra pills original
top erection pills – ed pumps vipps canadian pharmacy
price pro pharmacy canada canadian online pharmacies prescription drugs buy prescription drugs canada
escitalopram canada escitalopram 10 mg costescitalopram australia escitalopram generic
canadian pharmacy viagra – http://phapll.com/ canadian pharmacy no rx
buy generic viagra reviews order viagra in us viagra cost walmart
play casino – casino slot canadian pharmacy cialis
aripiprazole tablet aripiprazole 10 mg no prescriptionaripiprazole nz aripiprazole united states
viagra premature ejaculation cure viagra for females viagra for boys
payday cash loans in charlotte nc payday loan help in alabama payday loans on benefits direct lenders ontario
payday loans in gander nl payday loans sylmar suncorp home loan cash back
pioglitazone cheap pioglitazone 30 mg nzpioglitazone without prescription pioglitazone price
spironolactone price spironolactone 100 mg otcspironolactone medication spironolactone purchase
small payday loans near me payday loans that dont do teletrack cash advance biloxi ms
qual e a formula do cialis cialis mail order canada cialis farmacias guadalajara
direct deposit cash loans cash loan today bad credit personal cash loans in sumter sc
erectile dysfunction medicines – Sildalis online my canadian pharmacy reviews
purchase generic cialis – cialis 5 mg canadian pharmacy review
fexofenadine tablet fexofenadine 180 mg usafexofenadine medication fexofenadine canada
glimepiride tablet glimepiride 4mg costglimepiride nz glimepiride purchase
how to buy real cialis online cialis and aggression cialis generico Г© bom
where can i buy meclizine meclizine 25 mg canadameclizine tablets meclizine pills
leflunomide purchase leflunomide 20mg pillsleflunomide canada leflunomide nz
atomoxetine without a prescription atomoxetine 25 mg nzhow to buy atomoxetine atomoxetine canada
write college essays for money – http://essaywrw.com/ cheap custom essays
eassy writing – paperwriter thesis writer
casino online usa – vegas casino online canadian pharmacy meds